The Hidden Cost of Renouncing U.S. Citizenship: Taxes, Fees & Long-Term Implications

Introduction

The recent years have seen thousands of American citizens choosing to give up on their American citizenship. Although the number may seem small, the growing tendency of expatriates to give up on their citizenship, especially those who have lived abroad and who have complex tax obligations, is alarming.

Many complain about the burdensome compliance and the FATCA law along with double taxation and tax compliance as ways of justifying their decision to give up on their citizenship. What most do not take into consideration is the fact that renunciation is a lot more costly than the fee of around $2350 that branches of the consulate charge.

There is a whole category for the cost of renouncing U.S. citizenship that most people do not take into consideration which include compliance obligations, professional costs, the exit tax levied by the IRS, along with the consequential costs that range in the tens or more often, hundreds of thousands. This guide hopes to identify the costs, the formal steps that need to be taken in addition to the alternatives that need to be considered before arriving at the decision to untie yourself with the citizenship permanently.

Why Are People Renouncing U.S. Citizenship?

The United States is one of the rare nations in the world with the policies of placing taxes on the nation’s citizens income regardless of the country they reside in. For many expatriates, this leads to:

• Double taxation: Paying income tax in both the U.S. and the country of residence.
• Complex Compliance: Filling out forms like Form 8938 (FATCA reporting), FBAR (FinCEN Form 114), and complex foreign income declarations.
• Banking Issues: Many foreign banks shun U.S. clients to escape the hassle of FATCA reporting.
• Disclosures: Ongoing asset and financial account reporting inexplicably offshore to U.S. authorities.

While such burdens can be eased through de-nationalization, the consequential tax and legal ramifications must always be critically evaluated.

The Formal Renunciation Process

Like any other form of legal identity, U.S. citizenship cannot be revoked by merely submitting documents. In addition to paperwork, the following steps must be observed:

• Structured Appointment: Delayed due to the time restrictions of the Centre for the allotted courts for hearing preliminary interrogations (origins of attention can be vis-a-vis U.S. embassies and consulates).
• Oath of Renunciation: Accompanied by administrative Form DS-4080 (note: Oath must always be taken in the physical presence of an officer).
• Online Form Fillings: Form 8854, an obligatory U.S. Self Expatriation tax Form, must be accompanied by fiscal termination documents.

Failure to submit Form 8854 means the IRS still treats you as a U.S. tax citizen, even after a legal authentication at the State Department for renunciation.The IRS Exit Tax Explained

The IRS Exit Tax Explained

The exit tax is the most controversial, “under the radar” tax one can pay. Why? Because it is so large, a lot of people don’t notice it. Meaning, a lot of people pay it without realizing it. The IRS exit tax is paid under IRC 877A, and the people who pay it are known as “covered expatriates. ” Who are the “covered expatriate”? You are a covered expatriate, if:

• You have a net worth of $2.00 million on the day of expatriation.
• You have provisionally paid tax, and certified tax compliance forms on Form 8854, for 5 years and fail to pay tax at $ 201,000 over the 5 years before departing.
• You are over and above the average annual tax US citizens pay, and are liable to pay, the tax in the last 5 years in the amount of $ 201,000.

How the exit tax works 

• The day before expatriation, you are considered to have “sold” and liquidated every single one of your assets under your name in every country in the world.
• If you are able to Exit and you have unrealized gains that apply over and beyond the “exemption amount,” you are billed “$866,000 in 2025” because you are charged leveraged tax gains as profit gains (ordinary 20% gain on profit tax in the world).
• If you have Pensions, or the tax deferring accounts like 401(K), or IRAs, you will get billed on separable tax, or withholding tax on.

Take for example:

If a person owns portfolio stock, real estate, or a business situated in a different country that is appreciated, when it comes to IRS exit tax, that person has to pay despite the fact that the person is owning hundreds of global assets.

A retirement account is most often bank accounts in different countries PFICs or Passive Foreign Investment Companies also have strict punitive tax guidelines.

Other Hidden Costs of Renunciation

While the exit tax gets most of the attention, there are additional financial, legal, and personal consequences:

1. Professional fee: Take for instance the ability to streamline renunciation even with a relatively simpler assets and tax structure you having to pay tax attorneys and international legal experts can be $5000 to even $25000.
2. Emotional and Personal Impact: There is also the complicated emotional aspect of feeling the loss of the sense of self and self worth coupled with the loss of marriage may also shatter personal relationships.
3. Travel and Residency Restrictions: On the contrary the frustration of even minor banking issues can be constraining, and coupled with the frustration along with the lapse of automatic residency and citizenship status, to even the US can be teetering on the brink of legal turmoil.
4. Estate and Gift Tax Complications: Nonetheless, people with no direct ties to the country can also suffer from the IRS exit tax and complications on gifting and inheritances along with the estate can also push one over the legal cliff with a 40% bump.

IRS Compliance Burden Before Renunciation

To avoid being classified as a covered expatriate, you must certify full tax compliance for the five years before expatriation. Examples of this include:

• Unfiled tax returns must be paid, and any outstanding taxes must be paid.
• FBAR and FATCA foreign accounts.
• Unfiled complex investment issues include PFIC reporting.
• The longer the delay, the more severe the penalties.

Alternatives to Renunciation

You may wish to consider the following actions before losing your citizenship:

• Foreign taxed credits, also known as foreign earned income exclusion credits, reduce taxable income by as much as $126,500.
• Tax liability payments of a resident in the U.S. to the country of residence.
• Agreements between countries to eliminate double taxation.
• Having a well-defined plan in place. In certain situations, strategically placed investments and income-producing assets may mitigate exposure.

How DimovTax Can Help

The fee for losing your citizenship may be offset by the increased cost of a financial blunder. And, Dimov Tax can help you with:

• Proposed calculations for potential liabilities that must be paid.
• Compliance and review for five years as well as preparation of Form 8854.
• IRS inquiries protection and cross-border gift tax assisted by audits.
• Reviewing various options to determine whether this is indeed the best path—or if there are more advantageous options to consider.

FAQs